Brooklyn Bedding builds conventional foam and pocketed-coil hybrids in a wide firmness range. Purple builds everything around a buckling-column gel grid. Here is how the two feel, who each one suits, and what to test in person.
These two brands started in the same place, selling mattresses online in a box, and then went in opposite directions. Brooklyn Bedding builds fairly conventional foam and pocketed-coil beds in its own Arizona factory and sells them in a wide range of firmness options. Purple built its whole identity around one unusual material: a hyper-elastic polymer molded into a hollow grid that buckles under pressure points and stays rigid everywhere else. Choosing between them is less about which is better and more about whether you want a familiar mattress feel done well or a genuinely different one.
Pick Brooklyn Bedding if you want a normal-feeling mattress with a firmness you can actually specify, if you sleep on your side or share the bed with a restless partner, or if you want a coil-based hybrid with real edge support. Pick Purple if pressure relief and heat are your main problems, if you have tried memory foam and found it too hot or too sinking, and if you are open to a mattress that feels unlike anything you have slept on before. Purple's grid is the most polarizing surface in the category: people who love it rarely go back, and people who dislike it usually know within a week.
| Brooklyn Bedding | Purple | |
|---|---|---|
| Construction | All-foam and hybrid models with pocketed coils under a foam comfort layer; some models use latex-style responsive foam | A buckling-column gel grid over foam, or over pocketed coils in the hybrid models |
| Feel and firmness range | Broad, from very soft to very firm; most models are offered in more than one firmness | Narrower; a distinctive springy, floating feel with limited firmness choice |
| Best suited sleeper | Side sleepers, couples with different preferences, anyone who wants to pick a firmness | Hot sleepers, back sleepers, people with hip or shoulder pressure points |
| Motion isolation | Good on all-foam models, moderate on hybrids with a firmer coil unit | Very good; the grid absorbs movement locally rather than transmitting it |
| Cooling | Good on hybrids thanks to coil airflow; foam models depend on the comfort layer | Excellent; the open grid is mostly air by volume |
| Edge support | Strong on the hybrid models with reinforced perimeters | Weaker; the grid compresses noticeably at the edge on the foam-based models |
| Typical price tier | Entry-level to mid-range, with premium hybrids at the top of the line | Mid-range to premium |
| Trial and warranty | Both brands sell direct with a home trial and a long limited warranty; check the current terms on each model before you buy, as they change | Same, and terms differ by model |
| Where to buy | Online, and in our LA showrooms, since we carry Brooklyn Bedding | Online and through third-party retailers; we do not stock Purple |
Brooklyn Bedding's real advantage is that it owns its factory. The price for the amount of material you get tends to be favorable, and the range is unusually wide. Most of the line comes in more than one firmness, which matters more than people expect: firmness is the single variable most likely to make you return a mattress, and choosing it up front removes the biggest source of regret.
The hybrid models work best for most people. A pocketed-coil unit gives you airflow, a supportive push back when you press into it, and a perimeter that holds when you sit on the side of the bed to put your shoes on. Side sleepers generally do well on the softer versions; back and stomach sleepers do well on the firmer ones.
Where it falls short: the all-foam models are less distinctive and compete in a crowded space, and the sheer number of models and firmness combinations makes the line confusing to shop online. This is one of the few cases where lying on the thing for ten minutes settles a decision an hour of reading cannot.
Purple's grid does something no foam does. Because it is a molded lattice of hollow columns, it stays firm under broad, light contact (your back, your thighs) and collapses only where pressure concentrates (your shoulder, your hip). The result supports you like something firm while relieving pressure like something soft. If your complaint about firm mattresses is shoulder pain and your complaint about soft ones is sinking, that combination is worth taking seriously.
It is also the coolest-sleeping surface here by a clear margin. The grid is largely open air, so body heat vents sideways instead of pooling under you. In a Los Angeles bedroom without air conditioning in September, that is a real difference rather than a marketing point.
Where it falls short: the feel is unusual and some people never adapt to it, edge support on the foam-based models is soft, the mattresses are heavy to move, and the firmness options are limited, so if the grid is close but not quite right for you there is less room to adjust.
Both can work, by different routes. Brooklyn Bedding's softer hybrid firmnesses let your shoulder and hip sink into a plush comfort layer over supportive coils. Purple relieves those same pressure points by letting the grid columns buckle beneath them without softening the rest of the bed. If you carry more weight in your shoulders and hips, the Purple approach tends to feel more supported. If you simply like the sensation of a cushioned surface, go with a plush hybrid. Our guide to testing a mattress in store explains what to actually check when you lie down.
Purple wins on paper and usually in practice. A Brooklyn Bedding hybrid closes most of the gap because the coil layer moves air, but an all-foam model will not. If cooling is your first priority, look at grid or coil constructions and avoid thick memory foam comfort layers regardless of brand. Our hybrid mattresses are the category to start in.
Purple's grid is excellent at containing movement, so a partner getting up at 5am is less disruptive. Brooklyn Bedding's all-foam models match that; its firmer hybrids transmit a little more. The bigger issue for couples is usually disagreement about firmness, and there Brooklyn Bedding's split options and wide firmness range give you more to work with.
Neither brand is a treatment, and be skeptical of anyone who tells you otherwise. What helps is keeping your spine roughly level, which usually means medium-firm support with enough give at the shoulder and hip. Both brands can deliver that. The difference is that with Brooklyn Bedding you choose the firmness, and with Purple you accept the grid's characteristic feel. See our medium-firm mattresses for the range most people with back pain land on.
Brooklyn Bedding generally costs less for a comparable build, particularly in the entry and mid tiers. Purple's foam-based models start lower than its hybrids but the grid technology carries a premium throughout the line.
We stock Brooklyn Bedding, so you can lie on it in any of our five LA showrooms rather than guessing from a website. That is worth doing, because firmness perception is personal and a number on a chart tells you very little.
We do not carry Purple. If you have tried it and liked the cool, buoyant, pressure-relieving feel but want something you can test in person, the closest things we stock are a Brooklyn Bedding hybrid in a firmer setting, or a latex build from Birch or Savvy Rest. Latex shares Purple's responsive character and its resistance to sinking, without the memory foam hug. If what you liked was the deep contouring rather than the bounce, Tempur-Pedic is the better direction, and we carry that too. Our bed-in-a-box guide covers how online-native brands differ from traditional ones, and our memory foam mattresses are the category to compare against for the opposite feel.
Every mattress we sell comes with a free 120-night comfort guarantee and same-day delivery across much of Los Angeles, so the decision does not have to be final on the showroom floor.
It is a well-regarded value brand. Because the company manufactures its own mattresses rather than outsourcing, it tends to offer more material and more firmness choice at a given price than comparable online brands. The hybrids with pocketed coils are the strongest part of the line. Whether it is right for you comes down to picking the correct firmness, which is why trying one in person helps.
Brooklyn Bedding manufactures in its own facility in Arizona. That vertical integration is the main reason the brand can offer so many firmness variations and custom sizes without the lead times you would expect from a company that relies on outside factories.
For the right sleeper, yes. The grid is genuinely effective at relieving pressure points while keeping the rest of the body supported, and it sleeps cooler than almost anything else on the market. The caveat is that the feel is distinctive and not universally liked, and edge support on the foam-based models is soft. It is a mattress worth lying on before buying rather than ordering on reputation.
The signature layer is a hyper-elastic polymer molded into a hollow column grid, sitting on top of polyurethane foam support layers. The hybrid models replace part of that foam with a pocketed coil unit. The grid is what creates both the cooling and the unusual buckling response under pressure points.
Expect a lifespan broadly in line with other quality mattresses, roughly seven to ten years depending on use, body weight and the support base underneath it. The grid material itself is durable; the foam layers beneath it tend to be the limiting factor, as they are in most mattresses. Our guide to how long mattresses last covers the warning signs to watch for.
If you are torn between a grid, a hybrid and a foam bed, the honest answer is that you will not resolve it by reading more comparisons. Take our sleep quiz for a firmness and material recommendation based on how you actually sleep, then come test the result in one of our Los Angeles showrooms. Ten minutes on your usual sleeping side tells you more than any spec sheet.
Skip the comparison shopping. Answer a few questions and we'll narrow it down to the mattresses that actually fit your sleep style.
Buying guides and sleep advice, no email signup required.
